Back to Climate News
Columbia Climate Law BlogColumbia Climate Law Blog

Climate Change, the Courts and US policy – a Critical Perspective From a Former Judge of the UK Supreme Court

Abatify Summary

Nature & Climate Perspective

The judiciary acts as a volatile but essential arbiter for the permanence of carbon sequestration projects by defining legal accountability for ecological damage.

  • Judicial precedents regarding climate liability directly influence the security and long-term viability of LULUCF (Land Use, Land-Use Change, and Forestry) projects.
  • Legal recognition of the 'duty of care' provides a framework for protecting biodiversity hotspots from industrial encroachment that would otherwise compromise nature-based carbon sinks.
  • Stricter legal interpretations of environmental harm discourage 'carbon ranching' that lacks ecological integrity, favoring projects with high biodiversity co-benefits.

Market & Policy Outlook

A fragmented judicial approach across jurisdictions creates significant financial risk and regulatory uncertainty for ICVCM-aligned market mechanisms.

  • The contrast between UK judicial activism and US skepticism toward administrative power creates a 'compliance canyon' for corporations managing Scope 3 emissions reporting.
  • Inconsistent rulings on corporate fiduciary duty relative to climate risk undermine the stability of SBTi (Science Based Targets initiative) commitments and long-term carbon pricing.
  • Judicial challenges to regulatory oversight hinder the development of standardized ITMOs (Internationally Transferred Mitigation Outcomes) under Article 6.2, limiting global market liquidity.
Introduction As a British judge with a special interest in environmental law, I have over the last two decades taken a particular interest in the developing role of the courts across the world in response to the challenges of climate change. In this article I shall look back at my perceptions of the responses of […]
Introduction As a British judge with a special interest in environmental law, I have over the last two decades taken a particular interest in the developing role of the courts across the world in response to the challenges of climate change. In this article I shall look back at my perceptions of the responses of […]

This story moves you. Here's what you can do.

Take Action
“I want to act on my climate impact.”
Know Your Impact
“I want to know my climate impact.”
Read full article at Columbia Climate Law Blog
Article 6.2Scope 3LULUCFSBTiICVCM Core Carbon PrinciplesITMOs

Related Resources

Sourcing:

Contact our trading desk for customized environmental commodities for your needs

Request sourcing: Article 6.2 (ITMOs)